Tag Archives: Unreasonable

Criminal Practice – Voluntary Manslaughter – Self-Defense – Unreasonable Belief – Aggressor & Excessive Force – Jury Request – Witness’s Testimony (access required)

State v. Presson Defendant was not entitled to a dismissal based on perfect self-defense where the state presented evidence that the victim was unarmed, defendant left their fight to retrieve a knife, and defendant’s only injury was some blood on his knuckles while the victim had, among many injuries, 33 knife wounds

Read More »

Criminal Practice – Search & Seizure – Strip Search – Public Residential Street – Knife Use — Unreasonable (access required)

U.S. v. Edwards Although police did not completely pull down defendant’s pants during a search incident to his arrest on a public residential street, but shone a flashlight down his pants and then used a knife to cut a sandwich baggie with suspected narcotics off defendant’s genitals, the search was a strip search that violated defendant’s Fourth Amendment rights, and the 4th Circuit vacates defendant’s drug conviction.

Read More »

Criminal Practice – Search & Seizure – Anonymous Tip – ‘Shots Fired’ – High Crime Neighborhood – ‘Nervous’ Man – Pat-Down — Unreasonable (access required)

U.S. v. Massenburg Police officers responding to an anonymous tip about “shots fired” in a high-crime neighborhood, who saw four young men several blocks from the reported gunfire, did not have reasonable, particularized suspicion to conduct a pat-down of one of the young men who appeared nervous and refused consent to search; the 4th Circuit reverses defendant’s conviction on marijuana and firearm charges.

Read More »

Criminal Practice – Search & Seizure – Schoolchild – Strip Search — ‘Bra Lift’ – Unreasonable (access required)

In re T.A.S. The principal of an alternative school was informed by students that pills of a type that “would cause kids to be unsafe” were coming into the school. This did not justify searches that required a 13-year-old girl, in front of a member of the opposite sex, to reach under her shirt and lift her bra away from her body. We reverse the trial court’s denial of respondent’s motion to suppress.

Read More »